KiwiDave wrote:Reason for compression loss found Ian, more tomorrow. I'm told that 'borescope' is the correct term although boroscope is accepted.
TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
- ian65
 - Admin

 - Posts: 6402
 - Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2011 12:11 am
 - Has thanked: 315 times
 - Been thanked: 376 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
1999 Jaguar XJR V8 Supercharged
1992 Peugeot 205 1.9 GTI
2003 Mercedes SLK 200 Kompressor
- 
				TOOL
 - VIP User

 - Posts: 2598
 - Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2011 10:30 am
 - Location: Switzerland
 - Been thanked: 24 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
Just a quick edit:
The shot of the underside of the motor is in fact your new engine, not the old one. This was in my red RX2, so we had to swap the sumps and strainers over.
The oil strainers are "unsure" on the left (the smaller one) and RX2 on the right (the bigger one). The RX2 has a reverse bump sump, hence why we had to change it.
The oldschool "m" logo is on the longer through bolt, to help identify it. It is one of the 2 bolts that sits at the bottom, outside of the face of the rear plate.
Dave's old motor is completely apart.
			
			
									
						The shot of the underside of the motor is in fact your new engine, not the old one. This was in my red RX2, so we had to swap the sumps and strainers over.
The oil strainers are "unsure" on the left (the smaller one) and RX2 on the right (the bigger one). The RX2 has a reverse bump sump, hence why we had to change it.
The oldschool "m" logo is on the longer through bolt, to help identify it. It is one of the 2 bolts that sits at the bottom, outside of the face of the rear plate.
Dave's old motor is completely apart.
Back in the UK for the summer, maybe longer......
			
						- 
				KiwiDave
 - VIP User

 - Posts: 2268
 - Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2011 8:07 pm
 - Location: Feltham, Southwest London
 - Has thanked: 482 times
 - Been thanked: 192 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
Anyway ... moving on. The rear housing and rotor are good. Ok, so the housing is missing chrome here and there but, if you recall, the compression numbers made for very good reading. These later 12a's are very resiliant. Missing chrome doesn't necessarily equate to missing compression.

Rather nice flash bounce lighting effects here. Not intentional but still quite funky
 


So, no real surprises there then. The front is another world, all carnage and evil. It transpires that it is also, unfortunately, down to me and not an act of God. I spent a few days fooling about with pretty colored vac hoses and changed them around a few times (you may recall if you follow this thread). This necessitated the removal of the blue box several times and several times again.
At some point during this process, I mislaid the very small washer which goes with the retaining nut (wingnut no longer present). I was very careful with this washer, lest it should find it's way into places it should not venture. So. I was somewhat alarmed when said washer went awol and had a good look down thru the carb just in case ... and held my breath upon starting it up. And sigh of relief when it started ok.
A bit beat up here. Not all bad news though as a nice street port job will extend past the damaged area.

Something's taken out the edge of the apex seal

Something evil going on here
 That's rotor lightening but not in a good way   
 


Evil stuff ... all mother of damage and toasted housing


The culprit! on the left outer edge


Can you tell what it is yet??

I knew what it was as soon as I saw it ...

The remains of the small washer from the air cleaner! I obviously didn't look hard enough. It must have sat in the secondary inlet until they opened sufficiently and then some sort of dark magic has occurred.

So boys and girls, the moral of the story is ... be fecking careful when you have the top of the carb exposed. If you suspect anything has gone down there, remove the carb completely and have a good look around. It may cost you an inlet manifold gasket but that's a small price to pay. Ask me how I know
			
			
									
						
Rather nice flash bounce lighting effects here. Not intentional but still quite funky


So, no real surprises there then. The front is another world, all carnage and evil. It transpires that it is also, unfortunately, down to me and not an act of God. I spent a few days fooling about with pretty colored vac hoses and changed them around a few times (you may recall if you follow this thread). This necessitated the removal of the blue box several times and several times again.
At some point during this process, I mislaid the very small washer which goes with the retaining nut (wingnut no longer present). I was very careful with this washer, lest it should find it's way into places it should not venture. So. I was somewhat alarmed when said washer went awol and had a good look down thru the carb just in case ... and held my breath upon starting it up. And sigh of relief when it started ok.
A bit beat up here. Not all bad news though as a nice street port job will extend past the damaged area.

Something's taken out the edge of the apex seal

Something evil going on here


Evil stuff ... all mother of damage and toasted housing


The culprit! on the left outer edge


Can you tell what it is yet??

I knew what it was as soon as I saw it ...

The remains of the small washer from the air cleaner! I obviously didn't look hard enough. It must have sat in the secondary inlet until they opened sufficiently and then some sort of dark magic has occurred.

So boys and girls, the moral of the story is ... be fecking careful when you have the top of the carb exposed. If you suspect anything has gone down there, remove the carb completely and have a good look around. It may cost you an inlet manifold gasket but that's a small price to pay. Ask me how I know
1985 Sunrise Red S3 TWR
2006 Mercedes CLK 280 Sport AMG
			
						2006 Mercedes CLK 280 Sport AMG
- ian65
 - Admin

 - Posts: 6402
 - Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2011 12:11 am
 - Has thanked: 315 times
 - Been thanked: 376 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
Bloody hell Dave.... all this grief from a simple thing like that.... How much edge chrome flaking do you have on the good housing?
			
			
									
						1999 Jaguar XJR V8 Supercharged
1992 Peugeot 205 1.9 GTI
2003 Mercedes SLK 200 Kompressor
- 
				Lucky
 - VIP User

 - Posts: 2685
 - Joined: Mon Nov 07, 2011 8:30 pm
 - Location: Worthing, UK
 - Been thanked: 5 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
That's a bit horrid, dude  
 I've blown up some motors but never yet managed to replicate the cover of Joy Division's Unknown Pleasures via the medium of housing scores  
  What you've done there is you've mullered that. Really  
 
Thanks for taking one for the team and demonstrating what can go wrong from the simplest bits of maintenance
			
			
									
						Thanks for taking one for the team and demonstrating what can go wrong from the simplest bits of maintenance
- 
				KiwiDave
 - VIP User

 - Posts: 2268
 - Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2011 8:07 pm
 - Location: Feltham, Southwest London
 - Has thanked: 482 times
 - Been thanked: 192 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
Bugger! I thought it might polish outLucky wrote: What you've done there is you've mullered that. Really![]()
Shame of it is that the housing would have been well re usable sans the horror flick artwork. Anyway, I have the housing and rotor in my little rotorcave. Plan is to get them cleaned up and then painted or chromed and put on display (well, in a few years after the hurt has gone).
1985 Sunrise Red S3 TWR
2006 Mercedes CLK 280 Sport AMG
			
						2006 Mercedes CLK 280 Sport AMG
- 
				TOOL
 - VIP User

 - Posts: 2598
 - Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2011 10:30 am
 - Location: Switzerland
 - Been thanked: 24 times
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
Let's just say it was very well embedded in the housing and leave it at that. I had a hard time getting it back out.
One apex seal smashed to bits but still in it's slot. The others were missing the ends near the assist piece. Dave has the rotor. This rotor gave 0 comp on all 3 faces for a reason.
It'll look good on a shelf.
I have the good used 12A housing in my possession
			
			
									
						One apex seal smashed to bits but still in it's slot. The others were missing the ends near the assist piece. Dave has the rotor. This rotor gave 0 comp on all 3 faces for a reason.
It'll look good on a shelf.
I have the good used 12A housing in my possession
Back in the UK for the summer, maybe longer......
			
						- 
				apexheid
 
Re: TWiR 1986 S3 TWR
That was very bad luck...
About 5+ years ago, my son went into my garage without my knowing. Removed huge tall KN filter,guess what and he dropped the big screw into the 51 IDA.
He put the the filter lid back and left as it..
I went in the garage later in the evening after work, spotted something odd about it in engine bay..the filter's lid was not set up my way of bolted on and found the screw missed.
My horror was that the engine was a PP motor, removed the lid and found the screw was rested on the butterfly.
Managed to removed it with a magnetic prong.
The trick was to stop the wee monkey removed the screw, taped over with strip of black tape over the screw.
			
			
									
						About 5+ years ago, my son went into my garage without my knowing. Removed huge tall KN filter,guess what and he dropped the big screw into the 51 IDA.
He put the the filter lid back and left as it..
I went in the garage later in the evening after work, spotted something odd about it in engine bay..the filter's lid was not set up my way of bolted on and found the screw missed.
My horror was that the engine was a PP motor, removed the lid and found the screw was rested on the butterfly.
Managed to removed it with a magnetic prong.
The trick was to stop the wee monkey removed the screw, taped over with strip of black tape over the screw.
	